Latest News

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio Refuses to Comment on India's Handling of Protests

Rubio describes 'UN experts' as an 'oxymoron', says domestic political matters must be decided by the people of the country concerned

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has declined to weigh in on the United Nations' criticism of India's handling of protests, describing the term 'UN experts' as an 'oxymoron'. Rubio made the comments in response to a reporter's question about protests by opposition parties and students in India, and the UN experts' allegations of a crackdown.

Rubio said that domestic political matters must be decided by the people of the country concerned, and that the US would not get involved in India's internal political affairs. 'This is a democracy. They have elections here. So I am not going to align on their domestic political matters,' he said.

The US Secretary of State distinguished between peaceful protests and riots involving vandalism, arson, and destruction of property, saying that demonstrations and the expression of differing political opinions were part of democratic discourse. He cited Cuba as a contrast, where opposition voices face restrictions, including the risk of imprisonment, oppression, or exile.

Earlier, India had exposed the double standards of the United Nations and its frontal organisations, after contrasting stands were taken by representatives to paint protests in India as an issue of alleged human rights abuse. Indian diplomat Barkha Tamrakar addressed the Assembly on Tuesday, saying that India's constitutional safeguards, including Article 21 of the Constitution, protect human rights and ensure due process.

Tamrakar stressed that human rights should not be used as an instrument of political pressure or selective targeting of countries. 'India firmly opposes any attempt to convert unverified allegations, incomplete statistics, or a report that contains no India country observation into a negative characterization of the world's largest democracy,' she said.

The strong rebuttal came after UN experts had claimed that authorities in India were restricting peaceful assembly and indulging in 'enforced disappearances'. In contrast, UN Human Rights Chief Volker Türk took a much milder stand when speaking about the police crackdown on violent protests in France and other parts of Europe, even calling protestors 'vandals'.

India has strongly opposed characterisations based on unverified allegations, incomplete statistics, or reports lacking India-specific observations. The country has emphasized the need for impartial and evidence-based engagement on human rights issues.

The US Secretary of State's comments come as India and the US are working to strengthen their bilateral relationship, with President Trump confirming that a US-India trade deal is in the works. The deal is expected to boost trade and investment between the two countries, and is seen as a key aspect of their growing strategic partnership.

India's Response to UN Criticism

India has been facing criticism from the UN over its handling of protests, with some experts alleging that the government is restricting peaceful assembly and indulging in human rights abuses. However, the Indian government has maintained that it is committed to upholding human rights and ensuring due process.

The Indian diplomat, Barkha Tamrakar, emphasized that human rights should not be used as a tool for political pressure or selective targeting of countries. She said that India opposes any attempt to convert unverified allegations or incomplete statistics into a negative characterization of the country.

US-India Relations

The US and India have been working to strengthen their bilateral relationship, with a focus on trade, investment, and strategic cooperation. The two countries have a long-standing partnership, and the US has been supportive of India's growing role in regional and global affairs.

The US Secretary of State's comments on India's handling of protests reflect the US government's commitment to respecting the sovereignty and democratic processes of other countries. The US has emphasized the importance of peaceful protests and the expression of differing political opinions, and has encouraged India to ensure that its citizens' rights are protected.

In conclusion, the US Secretary of State's refusal to comment on India's handling of protests reflects the US government's commitment to respecting the sovereignty and democratic processes of other countries. The issue highlights the complexities of human rights and democracy, and the need for impartial and evidence-based engagement on these issues.